Arts >> Dance >> Dance Other

Lochinvar's "Lie" to Dance with Ellen: A Polite Evasion, Not a Falsehood

In Sir Walter Scott's Marmion (Canto V), Lochinvar doesn't lie—he uses a social convention to override the Laird of Buccleuch's reluctance.

The Exchange

  1. The Laird hesitates: Lochinvar is a border reiver (enemy clan).
  2. Lochinvar requests "one little minute" to dance, citing "a custom of old" and "courtesy to the fair."
  3. The Laird, bound by hospitality codes, cannot refuse a "courtesy" without appearing churlish.

Why It Works

It's a rhetorical maneuver, not a falsehood. Lochinvar exploits the Laird's honor culture. The poem celebrates audacity over deceit.

Dance Other

Related Categories