Neither has fully disclosed exact reasons, but based on interviews, lyrics, and reports, key factors include:
Global tours, filming, and living in different countries (Canada/US) made consistent time together nearly impossible.
They met as teens. As they matured, their values, priorities, and identities diverged.
Relentless media attention, fan pressure, and social media amplification strained privacy and trust.
Repeated rumors of infidelity (especially involving Justin) eroded trust. Gomez's songs ("Lose You to Love Me," "The Heart Wants What It Wants") hint at betrayal.
Both faced mental health struggles (Gomez: lupus, anxiety, depression; Bieber: depression, substance use). They needed space to heal individually.
This definitively ended any reconciliation hopes.
Ultimately, a high-pressure young love that couldn't survive adulthood's demands. Both have since spoken of mutual respect and closure.