Arts >> Dance >> Ballet

Lucille Ball and *Gone with the Wind*: A Casting Myth Debunked

Lucille Ball was never considered for Scarlett O'Hara. Full stop.

The legendary "Search for Scarlett" (1937–1938) tested over 30 actresses, including the era's biggest stars:

Vivien Leigh, a relative unknown in Hollywood, won the role after a chance meeting with George Cukor (then director) and a screen test that stunned David O. Selznick.

Why the confusion? Lucille Ball was a contract player at RKO and later MGM in the late 30s/early 40s, known for "B-movies" and comedy (Stage Door, The Big Street). She lacked the dramatic gravitas and "Southern belle" archetype Selznick demanded. Her iconic role, Lucy Ricardo (I Love Lucy, 1951), was a decade away. Ball herself laughed at the idea in later interviews, noting she was "too broad" for Scarlett.

Ballet

Related Categories