Arts >> Books >> Poetry

Macbeth's Paradox: Dismissing the Witches While Obeying Them

Macbeth's central contradiction: he articulates skepticism about the witches yet consistently acts on their prophecies. This isn't inconsistency—it's the tragedy's engine.

Explicit Dismissal (Act 1.3)

"Instruments of darkness tell us truths / Win us with honest trifles, to betray's / In deepest consequence." He knows they're demonic manipulation.

Contradictory Actions

  1. Murders Duncan to fulfill "king hereafter"
  2. Orders Banquo's death to thwart "father of kings"
  3. Seeks witches again (Act 4) for more prophecies
  4. Clings to "none of woman born" / "Birnam Wood" as invincibility guarantees

Key Contradiction Scenes

Act 3.4 (Banquet): Seeing Banquo's ghost: "I am afraid to think what I have done; / Look on't again I dare not." He cannot face consequences of acting on prophecies he claims to distrust.

Act 5.3 (vs. Macduff): Dismisses Macduff's threat, then shaken by "untimely ripped" revelation—proving he internally credits the prophecy he outwardly scorned.

Psychological Anatomy

The contradiction is the tragedy: Macbeth is torn between knowing the witches are evil and needing their promises to be true. He's not fooled—he's complicit in his own fooling.

Poetry

Related Categories