Macbeth's central contradiction: he articulates skepticism about the witches yet consistently acts on their prophecies. This isn't inconsistency—it's the tragedy's engine.
"Instruments of darkness tell us truths / Win us with honest trifles, to betray's / In deepest consequence." He knows they're demonic manipulation.
Act 3.4 (Banquet): Seeing Banquo's ghost: "I am afraid to think what I have done; / Look on't again I dare not." He cannot face consequences of acting on prophecies he claims to distrust.
Act 5.3 (vs. Macduff): Dismisses Macduff's threat, then shaken by "untimely ripped" revelation—proving he internally credits the prophecy he outwardly scorned.
The contradiction is the tragedy: Macbeth is torn between knowing the witches are evil and needing their promises to be true. He's not fooled—he's complicit in his own fooling.