Bard and Thranduil Urge Bilbo to Leave After Arkenstone Delivery
After Bilbo gives them the Arkenstone (as a bargaining chip to avert war), Bard and the Elvenking Thranduil urge Bilbo to leave the Lonely Mountain immediately and return to the Shire.
Reasons
- Bilbo's Safety: They respect his courage but know Thorin's rage will be lethal. Bilbo is a non-combatant hobbit.
- Neutrality: They want no harm to come to the "burglar" who acted honorably.
- Strategy: With the Arkenstone, they have leverage to negotiate a fair share of the treasure for Lake-town and the Wood-elves without battle.
Bilbo's Choice
Bilbo refuses to leave, staying with the dwarves out of loyalty. He only departs after the Battle of Five Armies, escorting Thorin's body and returning home with Gandalf and Beorn.