Milton Hershey and Children: Philanthropy, Paternalism, and the School That Changed Everything
Milton Hershey's relationship with children was complex and contradictory, blending genuine, massive philanthropy with the controlling, assimilationist norms of the Progressive Era.
The Philanthropic Triumphs
- Milton Hershey School (1909): Founded the Hershey Industrial School for orphaned boys—free housing, education, vocational training, medical/dental care. Later expanded to girls (1977). His entire fortune was ultimately left to the school trust.
- Model Community: Built Hershey, PA with parks, a zoo, theater, pool, and trolley system—amenities for workers' families.
- Personal Touch: Anecdotes describe him visiting the school, knowing boys by name, handing out ice cream, attending graduations.
The Historical Criticisms
- Child Labor: His early Lancaster Caramel Factory (1880s–90s) employed children—standard for the era, exploitative by modern standards.
- Militaristic Discipline: The school operated on a quasi-military, religious regimen (uniforms, chores, mandatory church, limited family contact). Critics label it institutionalization.
- Absolute Control: He retained total control over the trust; the school served his vision of "useful citizens" (vocational over academic initially).
Verdict
He invested enormously in disadvantaged children's futures (arguably the largest private endowment for child care in US history), but through a controlling framework typical of his time. Not "warm" in a modern sense, but deeply committed to their material welfare.