Short answer: there is no mention of Lucy in Skillet's song "Monster." The name appears in a completely different track—"Lucy," a 2000 song from the band's Invincible EP. The lyric "Lucy, don't you go / The devil's at your door" suggests a narrative, but neither song reveals her fate. Lucy remains a lyrical character whose survival is left entirely unspecified.
"Monster" (2009, from Awake) is an anthem about inner struggle and spiritual warfare. "Lucy" (2000) is a haunting, earlier piece with a more personal, storytelling feel. Fans sometimes conflate them, but they belong to distinct chapters of Skillet's discography.
Both songs deal with dark themes—temptation, danger, redemption—and Skillet's lyrical universe often revisits motifs. However, there is no canonical link between the Lucy of the EP and the narrator of "Monster." The band has never clarified her story, leaving it open to interpretation.