The line comes from the spiritual "Were You There" — a cornerstone of the African American folk tradition.
Authorship: Unknown. Like most spirituals, it emerged communally—passed orally, shaped by generations of enslaved people, encoded with biblical narrative and coded resistance.
Structure: Call-and-response friendly. Each verse asks "Were you there when they [crucified / nailed / pierced / laid] my Lord?" Response: "Oh, sometimes it causes me to tremble, tremble, tremble."
Recorded by Mahalia Jackson, Johnny Cash, Marion Williams, and countless choirs. It's not a composed song—it's a communal prayer set to melody.