Arts >> Books >> Nonfiction

Shakespeare on Lawyers: Satire, Commentary, and Elizabethan Ambivalence

Shakespeare's references to lawyers range from savage satire to nuanced commentary on justice, reflecting Elizabethan ambivalence toward the legal profession.

1. The Famous Satire – Henry VI, Part 2 (4.2)

"The first thing we do, let's kill all the lawyers." — Dick the Butcher

Spoken by a rebel seeking to dismantle law itself. Context: lawyers upheld the feudal order the rebels hated. It's a villain's line, not Shakespeare's endorsement.

2. Lawyers as Flawed Pragmatists – Measure for Measure (2.2)

"They say best men are moulded out of faults, / And for the most become much more the better / For being a little bad..." — Duke (as Friar)

Suggests moral flexibility (like a lawyer's) can be pragmatic.

3. Mercy Over Legalism – The Merchant of Venice (4.1)

"The quality of mercy is not strained... It is twice blest: / It blesseth him that gives and him that takes." — Portia (disguised as lawyer)

The play's climax argues that equity must temper law.

4. The "Three-Pence Lawyer" – Twelfth Night (1.5)

"I was called 'Three-pence' by the other gentlemen here." — Sir Andrew Aguecheek

A "three-pence lawyer" was a cut-rate, incompetent attorney—mocking Sir Andrew's pretensions.

5. Hamlet's Cynicism – Hamlet (5.1)

In the graveyard, Hamlet mocks legalistic quibbling over Ophelia's burial rights, implying law serves power, not truth.

Summary

Shakespeare portrays lawyers as: necessary but corruptible, technical but sometimes blind to justice, and ripe for satire—reflecting Elizabethan ambivalence toward the legal profession.

Nonfiction

Related Categories