The phrase appears in Measure for Measure (Act 1, Scene 1), spoken by the Duke to Angelo: "For we have strict statutes and most biting laws, / The which for this nineteen years we have let sleep; / Even like an o'ergrown lion in a cave, / That goes not out to prey. Now, as fond fathers, / Having bound up the threat'ning twigs of birch, / Only to stick it in their children's sight / For terror, not to use; in time the rod / Becomes more mocked than feared: so our decrees, / Dead to infliction, to themselves are dead; / And liberty plucks justice by the nose; / The baby beats the nurse, and quite athwart / Goes all decorum. Fust in us unus'd / Are the first to be forgot."
Fust (verb, obsolete) = to grow musty, moldy, rot from disuse. Related to fusty—stale, stuffy.
Moral qualities—like laws, like birch rods—rot when unused. The virtues we don't exercise (courage, justice, mercy, discipline) don't wait patiently. They degrade. They become "fusty"—hollow performances rather than living capacities.
The Duke speaks this while pretending to leave Vienna, appointing Angelo to enforce the laws the Duke neglected. The Duke's own virtue—leadership—has "fust in us unus'd." He outsources his moral duty, then judges the result.
It's not just about governance. It's about character. The patience you don't practice vanishes when tested. The honesty you "save" for big moments fails in small ones. Virtue is a muscle, not a trophy.
Shakespeare's obsolete verb names a timeless truth: use it or lose it applies to the soul.