Anachronisms in Romeo and Juliet: What Shakespeare Got "Wrong" — And What He Didn't
Shakespeare wrote ~1595 about a story set in 13th–14th century Verona, using sources (Brooke 1562, Bandello 1554) that were already anachronistic. The play reflects Elizabethan England more than medieval Italy.
Commonly Cited Anachronisms
1. Firearms / Gunpowder Weapons
- Text: "Give me my long sword, ho!" (1.1) — but servants carry "partisans" (polearms). No guns in dialogue.
- Reality: Gunpowder weapons existed in 14th-c. Italy (early cannons, handgonnes), but not personal sidearms. Not a clear anachronism.
2. "Prince of Verona"
- Text: Prince Escalus rules Verona.
- Reality: 13th-c. Verona was a comune (republic) ruled by podestà, then the della Scala family (Signori). "Prince" (principe) as sovereign title emerges later. Plausible anachronism.
3. "Damask" Fabric
- Text: "Damask" mentioned in 4.4 (Capulet: "Go, be gone... / And hire those horses; I'll to the friar's cell... / ...damask...").
- Reality: Damask weaving reached Italy (Florence, Venice) by 14th century via Damascus/Syria trade. Not an anachronism.
4. Clocks Striking Hours
- Text: "The clock strikes twelve" (Juliet, 4.3).
- Reality: Mechanical striking clocks on public towers existed in Italy from late 13th c. (Padua 1273, Milan 1309). Accurate.
5. Apothecaries & Poisons
- Text: Romeo buys poison from apothecary (5.1).
- Reality: Guild-regulated apothecaries existed in 14th-c. Italian cities. Accurate.
6. Marriage Customs
- Text: Juliet near 14, arranged marriage to Paris, secret Friar ceremony.
- Reality: Canon law required banns or license; clandestine marriage valid but illicit. Council of Trent (1563) later mandated public ceremony. Plausible for pre-Trent.
Real Anachronisms: Elizabethan England in Verona
- Inns with "beds" for travelers (3.3) — more English than Italian.
- Nurse's role — wet-nurse/companion is English gentry custom.
- Capulet's "feast" with "musicians" — Elizabethan great house entertainment.
- Language: Puns, metaphors, insults work in English, not Italian.
Conclusion
Most "anachronisms" cited online (guns, damask, Prince) are not errors for the period. The true anachronism is cultural: Verona feels like 1590s London. Shakespeare wrote for his audience, not archaeologists.