By comparing Reverend Hale to Pontius Pilate, John Proctor implies that Hale, like Pilate who condemned Jesus despite knowing his innocence, acts in a self-serving and unjust manner. Proctor accuses Hale of deliberately or recklessly condemning innocent people as witches, even if Hale subconsciously knows they are innocent.
The allusion powerfully condemns Hale's character, suggesting he acts not from genuine belief in witchcraft but from desire for power, status, or conformity rather than standing for truth.