Legal Test for Obscenity: The Miller Standard (US) – Three-Prong Test
US obscenity law derives from Miller v. California (1973). A work is legally obscene only if it meets all three prongs:
- Prurient Interest: The average person, applying contemporary community standards, finds the work as a whole appeals to prurient (shameful/morbid sexual) interest.
- Patent Offensiveness: The work depicts/describes sexual conduct in a patently offensive way per community standards (specific acts defined by state law).
- Lack of Serious Value: The work lacks serious literary, artistic, political, or scientific value (objective, national standard—Pope v. Illinois, 1987).
Key nuances:
- "As a whole" – isolated scenes don't condemn the entire work.
- Community standards – vary by jurisdiction (local for prongs 1–2, national for prong 3).
- First Amendment protection – fails if any prong unmet.
- Child pornography – separate, stricter standard (New York v. Ferber); no value test needed.
State laws implement Miller with variations. Consult an attorney for specific cases.