Trenton Lee Stewart's series takes place in a contemporary early-2000s timeframe (approximately 2000–2005), evidenced by specific technological and cultural markers:
Stewart intentionally kept it slightly timeless—but the cultural texture anchors it to the early 2000s. The books were published 2007–2009, depicting a "recent past" familiar to the author.
The low-tech setting enables the plot: children solve puzzles through observation, deduction, and physical investigation—not Google searches or GPS tracking. The mystery requires that technological gap.