The John Peter Zenger Trial (1735) — Why It Mattered to American Colonists
The 1735 trial of printer John Peter Zenger was a watershed for press freedom in the American colonies — not because it changed the law immediately, but because it changed what colonists believed was possible.
The Case
- Zenger published the New-York Weekly Journal, criticizing Governor William Cosby (corruption, election rigging, French alliance rumors).
- Cosby charged Zenger with seditious libel — under English law, truth was not a defense. Criticizing government = crime, period.
- Zenger's lawyers (James Alexander, William Smith) were disbarred by Cosby's handpicked judge (James DeLancey).
- Andrew Hamilton (Philadelphia's top lawyer) stepped in pro bono.
Hamilton's Radical Argument
"The liberty of the press is essential to the liberty of the people. Truth should be a defense."
He appealed to the jury, not the judge — urging them to judge the facts, not the law.
The Verdict
Jury nullification. The jury acquitted Zenger in 10 minutes — defying the judge's instruction that truth was irrelevant. A political earthquake.
Why Colonists Cared
- Proof that power could be challenged. A royal governor's proxy lost to a printer and a jury.
- Weakened seditious libel. Prosecutors hesitated; printers grew bolder.
- Blueprint for revolutionary rhetoric. "Liberty of the press" became a rallying cry — cited in pre-Revolution pamphlets, committees of correspondence, Continental Congress debates.
- Established jury independence. Juries could check judicial overreach — a principle embedded in the 6th/7th Amendments.
Zenger didn't win a legal precedent (English law didn't change until 1792, US until 1798/1800s). But he won the moral and cultural precedent — the press could speak truth to power, and a jury of peers would protect it. That belief fueled 1776.