Value of 1940s Autograph Book with 43 Stars (Hayworth, Davis, Sinatra, etc.)
Impossible to Value Without Physical Inspection
Key factors determine value:
Critical Value Drivers
- Authentication: PSA/DNA, JSA, BAS certification essential. Uncertified = speculative.
- Signature Quality: Bold, clear, placement, ink contrast.
- Rarity/Desirability: Sinatra, Hayworth, Davis, Welles, Ball, Colbert, Garson, Haley, Durante = A-list. 43 signatures = exceptional.
- Condition: Page integrity, no fading/foxing, binding intact.
- Provenance: Who owned it? How acquired? Documentation adds value.
- Format: Bound book vs. loose pages. Original context (studio event, premiere?).
Rough Estimate (If All Authentic & Fine)
- Low end: $5,000–$10,000 (if condition/issues).
- Mid: $15,000–$30,000.
- High (auction, perfect): $50,000–$100,000+.
Sinatra alone (certified) = $1,500–$3,000+. Hayworth/Davis = $800–$2,000+ each. Welles = $1,000+. Ball = $500–$1,500. Colbert/Garson/Haley/Durante = $300–$800 each. Synergy of 43 in one book = premium.
Next Steps
- Do not remove pages.
- Contact Heritage Auctions, RR Auction, Bonhams (entertainment memorabilia depts).
- Submit for PSA/DNA or JSA authentication (fees ~$50–$100/sig).
- Get formal appraisal for insurance.