In 1550, a Dominican friar stood before Charles V's court in Valladolid and argued that Indigenous Americans were fully human—rational, soul-bearing, entitled to rights. That argument became In Defense of the Indians. Its author: Bartolomé de las Casas.
Las Casas arrived in Hispaniola in 1502 as a settler, received an encomienda (land grant with forced Indigenous labor), and participated in the system. But witnessing the brutality—massacres, enslavement, disease, cultural erasure—triggered a radical conversion. He renounced his grant, joined the Dominicans, and spent 50 years advocating for the people he once exploited.
In Defense of the Indians (originally Apologética historia sumaria / Brevísima relación de la destrucción de las Indias) systematically dismantled the justifications for conquest: that Indigenous people were "natural slaves" (Aristotle), lacked souls, or required forced conversion. Las Casas documented atrocities with legal precision—burnings, mutilations, infants thrown to dogs—arguing they violated natural law, canon law, and Spanish law.
The 1542 New Laws (restricting encomiendas) bore his influence. But enforcement failed; colonial interests prevailed. Las Casas died in 1566, marginalized. Yet his writings seeded modern human rights discourse—cited in 20th-century decolonization, liberation theology, and Indigenous rights movements. A conquistador's conscience became a colonized world's evidence.