Holden Caulfield writes his descriptive composition for Stradlater about his younger brother Allie’s baseball mitt.
Allie died of leukemia (July 18, 1946). The mitt, covered in poems Allie wrote in green ink, symbolizes his intelligence, sensitivity, and uniqueness. Holden describes Allie as “the most intelligent” and “nicest” family member—profoundly missed. The assignment triggers Holden’s grief and anger at a world that doesn’t value authenticity.
Stradlater’s dismissive reaction (“That’s not what the assignment was”) deepens Holden’s alienation.