- Tender Loving Greed (1986)
- I Am a Beggar (1988)
- Daughter of Jerusalem (1994)
- Till We Have Faces: A Mythic Tale of Christianity (1999)
- The Things I Do for Love (2005)
- From Man to Man (2008)
- Beautiful as Yesterday (2014)
Essays
- "On Being a Jewish Christian" (First Things, March 2001)
- "The Church and the Jews" (Touchstone, July/August 2001)
- "In Defense of Dialogue" (Commonweal, October 5, 2001)
- "The Importance of Being Catholic" (First Things, February 2002)
- "The End of History?" (Touchstone, July/August 2002)
- "The Power of Conversion" (The New Atlantis, Fall 2002)
- "The Scandal of Scandal" (Touchstone, January/February 2003)
- "The Crisis of Liberal Democracy" (First Things, March 2003)
- "The Challenge of Islam" (The New Atlantis, Summer 2003)
- "The Future of Christianity" (Touchstone, July/August 2003)
Memoirs
- Tender Mercies: A Memoir (2016)