Long John Silver: Good or Bad? (Treasure Island)
Neither—he's morally ambiguous. In Stevenson's Treasure Island, Silver is:
- Villainous: Pirate, mutineer, murderer, manipulator.
- Admirable: Brave, loyal to his crew, resourceful, charismatic, genuinely fond of Jim Hawkins.
- Pragmatic: Switches sides for survival; saves Jim at the end.
He defies binary labels—a charming rogue whose self-interest coexists with unexpected honor.