Was the Island in "Lost" Purgatory? No — Confirmed by Creators
No. Co-creator Damon Lindelof explicitly confirmed: the Island was not Purgatory.
What Actually Happened
- Island = Real — Physical place with electromagnetic anomalies, time shifts, healing properties
- Flash-sideways (Season 6) = Purgatory-like — Post-death meeting place where characters reconcile before moving on
- Finale reveals: All main characters died at different times; the sideways world was their collective construct to "find each other"
The Island was the crucible of their lives; the sideways world was the waiting room for the afterlife. Conflating the two misses the show's structural design.