Murderer in "The Adventure of Silver Blaze": Colonel Ross
The killer is Colonel Ross, the horse's owner—not the stable-boy John Straker.
How He Did It
- Silenced the watchdog: Used Straker's own tobacco to keep the dog quiet (the "curious incident of the dog in the night-time").
- Framed the horse: Had Straker lead Silver Blaze away, making it seem the horse fled with the body.
- Exploited horsemanship: Knew Silver Blaze would stay calm if handled correctly.
Motive: Gambling debt owed to Straker. A classic Holmes misdirection—Holmes deduces the truth from the dog's silence.