Stone-Giants in The Hobbit Chapter 5 (Not Chapter 4): Warning, Not Action
The Stone-giants appear in Chapter 5 ("Riddles in the Dark"), not Chapter 4. In the chapter:
- They are not shown acting directly.
- Gollum warns Bilbo they are dangerous and to be avoided.
- They represent a terrifying environmental threat, feared even more than dwarves by Gollum.
- Their implied presence amplifies the cavern's danger and mystery.
While inactive in the scene, their looming threat shapes the atmosphere.