Arguments for Dally being a hero:
* He sacrifices himself for Johnny: Dally's final act is to steal the gun and get himself killed by the police. He does this to save Johnny from facing the death penalty, proving he would do anything for his friend. This act of selflessness is definitely heroic.
* He protects his friends: Dally is fiercely loyal to the Greasers. He stands up for them when they're in trouble and even takes the blame for things he didn't do. This protective and loyal nature can be seen as heroic.
* He's tough and defiant: Dally embodies the rebellious spirit of the Greasers, standing up against societal expectations and fighting for what he believes in. This defiance, while sometimes destructive, can be interpreted as a form of heroism, especially in a world that seems to be against them.
Arguments against Dally being a hero:
* He's violent and reckless: Dally is involved in numerous fights and crimes. He also seems to enjoy the thrill of danger, putting himself and others at risk. This destructive behavior clashes with traditional notions of heroism.
* He struggles with anger and self-destruction: Dally's life is plagued by inner turmoil and a deep sense of hopelessness. He often lashes out at others and engages in self-destructive acts, which are not generally considered heroic traits.
* His actions often have negative consequences: While Dally tries to protect his friends, his recklessness sometimes leads to more trouble. This can be seen as a flaw that prevents him from being a true hero.
Ultimately, whether you consider Dally a hero depends on your interpretation of his actions and motivations. He is a complex and flawed character who embodies both heroic and villainous qualities. He is certainly a tragic figure, and his story highlights the complexities of heroism and the struggles of young people in a world that doesn't always understand them.