Marriage in Fielding's "Tom Jones": Love, Duty, Class, and 18th-Century Realities
Marriage is the novel's structuring institution — the endpoint toward which all plots converge. Fielding dissects it across five dimensions:
1. Love vs. Duty (The Central Dialectic)
- Tom + Sophia: Passion + virtue = ideal. Their love survives separation, class barriers, and Sophia's father's opposition.
- Allworthy + Bridget: Duty without passion → cold propriety.
- Captain Blifil + Bridget: Ambition disguised as duty → ruin.
Fielding argues: Love without duty is chaos; duty without love is tyranny. Harmony requires both.
2. Marriage as Social Contract (Class Mobility)
- Squire Western: Wants Sophia to marry Blifil for estate consolidation — "blood and money."
- Lady Bellaston: Uses marriage/affairs as power currency.
- Nightingale + Nancy: Merchant class — pragmatic affection, family approval negotiated.
- Tom + Sophia: Gentry + foundling → "true gentility" transcends birth. Fielding's meritocratic fantasy.
3. Gender Asymmetry
- Men's infidelity (Tom, Nightingale) = folly, forgivable.
- Women's chastity (Sophia, Harriet) = existential; loss = ruin.
- Fielding critiques but doesn't dismantle this — reflects 1740s reality.
4. Legal & Economic Undercurrents
- Entails, settlements, jointures dictate marital options.
- Tom's "fortune" (Allworthy's inheritance) resolves his eligibility.
- Fitzpatrick's abusive marriage to Harriet = legal trap (coverture).
5. Comic Resolution = Multiple Marriages
Book XVIII delivers: Tom/Sophia, Nightingale/Nancy, Mrs. Miller's daughter/partner, Partridge/gamekeeper's wife. Social order restored through sanctioned unions. Convention satisfied; subversion contained.
Fielding's Innovation
Unlike Richardson's Pamela (marriage as reward for virtue) or Defoe's Moll Flanders (marriage as survival), Fielding makes marriage a test of character — the arena where nature, nurture, and choice reveal the self.