- The locket: Mae Tuck wears a locket around her neck that contains a picture of her 10-year-old son, Jesse Tuck. Jesse drank from the spring when he was 10 years old and never aged past that point. Mae keeps the locket close to her as a reminder of her son and the cost of immortality.
- The horse, Black Beauty: Mae Tuck owns a black horse named Beauty that she uses to travel. Beauty is also said to be immortal, as she has not aged since Mae Tuck found her in the woods many years ago.