Arts >> Books >> Authors

David Tennant vs. Matt Smith: Which Doctor Is Better?

There is no objective "better" Doctor; preference depends on what you value in the portrayal. Both are critically acclaimed and beloved.

The Tenth Doctor (David Tennant, 2005–2010)

The Eleventh Doctor (Matt Smith, 2010–2013)

Quick Guide

PreferenceChoose
Darker, romantic, dramatic intensityTennant (10th)
Whimsical, complex arcs, fairy-tale vibeSmith (11th)
"Classic" modern Doctor feelTennant
Fresh, weird, unpredictable energySmith

Best advice: Watch Series 2–4 (Tennant) and Series 5–7 (Smith) to decide for yourself.

Authors

Related Categories