Arts >> Art >> Sculpture

Why Ismene Refuses to Help Antigone Bury Polynices: Fear, Duty, and Pragmatism

Ismene's refusal to join Antigone's burial plot isn't simple cowardice—it's a complex stance rooted in genuine fear, respect for authority, and a pragmatic assessment of consequences. Here's a breakdown of her reasoning.

1. Fear of the Death Penalty

Creon has explicitly decreed death for anyone burying Polynices. Ismene takes this threat literally and seriously. In a world where state power is absolute and execution public, her fear is rational, not merely weak.

2. Respect for State Authority and Gender Hierarchy

Her line—"We are women... not born to contend with men" (line 62)—encapsulates her worldview. She accepts the patriarchal order: men rule, women obey; the king commands, subjects submit. To her, defiance isn't brave—it's unnatural and doomed.

3. Pragmatism: No Benefit, Only Destruction

Ismene sees no practical upside. Polynices is dead; burying him won't restore him. The act would kill them both and leave their sister (and possibly others) alone. She calculates cost-benefit and finds only loss.

4. Religious Caution

She worries that defying the king might also offend the gods who uphold civic order. In Greek thought, the polis and the divine were intertwined; challenging one could destabilize the other.

The Irony of Her Later Reversal

When Antigone is caught, Ismene tries to share the blame—claiming she participated. Antigone rejects her, refusing to let her die for a deed she didn't do. Ismene's journey from refusal to attempted martyrdom underscores her conflicted position: she embodies conventional obedience, yet loves her sister enough to die with her.

Ismene isn't Antigone's foil in simplicity; she represents the ordinary human calculation that makes Antigone's absolute commitment so extraordinary—and so dangerous.

Sculpture

Related Categories