What Did Thorin Consider the Greatest Treasure in the Mountain?
Thorin Oakenshield never explicitly names a single "greatest treasure," but the narrative and his actions center on three intertwined prizes:
1. The Arkenstone (The Heart of the Mountain)
- A massive, multifaceted white gem emitting its own light.
- Symbol of the King under the Mountain's divine right to rule.
- Thorin: "That stone is beyond price... I would give a thousand armies for it."
2. The Restoration of Erebor & Dwarven Heritage
- Reclaiming the ancestral halls, forges, and kingdom.
- Restoring his people's honor, craft, and sovereignty after 150 years of exile.
3. The Gold & Jewels (Material Wealth)
- Necessary to rebuild Dale, equip armies, and secure alliances.
- But Thorin's "dragon-sickness" (greed/obsession) fixates on the hoard itself.
Ultimately: The Arkenstone is the symbolic greatest treasure; the kingdom is the practical one; the gold becomes his tragic obsession.