Preference is subjective. Comparison:
As I Lay Dying – metalcore (heavy riffs, breakdowns, guttural vocals).
Bullet for My Valentine – heavy metal with melodic/aggressive mix (screaming + clean vocals).
Both have solid fanbases, millions of sales, major tours, platinum albums.
As I Lay Dying pioneered NWOAHM (New Wave of American Heavy Metal). Bullet for My Valentine blended metal styles with melody.
Both have Grammy nominations and Metal Hammer/Kerrang! awards.
Both are respected in metal; choice depends on taste for metalcore vs. melodic heavy metal.