Bright blue. Explicitly described in both J.K. Rowling's novels and depicted in the films.
"His magical eye was bright blue, and it whirred and clicked as it spun around…" – Harry Potter and the Goblet of Fire, Chapter 14
Brendan Gleeson (Moody in Goblet of Fire, Order of the Phoenix) and the prop department rendered the magical eye as a vivid, electric blue prosthetic that contrasts sharply with his weathered face and normal brown eye. The color choice emphasizes the eye's unnatural, technological-magical nature—it's not a biological replacement but a constructed artifact.
It's a small detail that reinforces Moody's character: hyper-vigilant, artificially enhanced, visually arresting.